Stephen wrote:
> --- Natasa wrote:
>
>> Another naive detail in the series, IMO, is that the
>> rebellion's leaders all get on so
>> well. From the very beginning, the whole
>> anti-Federation movement is so
>> harmonious:
>
>The exception being the crew of the Liberator of
>course !
Yes, it has often occured to me that Blake's idealism wouldn't stand out so
much if he weren't surrounded by such 'untypical' rebels. In the galaxy
which must be full of discontent with the Federation government and millions
of angry, deprived citizens who would be more than willing to help Blake in
his fight, he somehow ends up with a small group of eccentrics who don't
give a monkey's about changing the world.
>Blake never has to
>worry about the morality of his allies torturing
>Federation prisoners or blowing up civilians.
Whereas this happens quite often in fanfic. Fanfic writers seem to have a
taste for positing moral dilemmas and depicting the rebellion in shades of gray.
>In fact
>he has to do a deal with an organised crime syndicate
>to encounter morally dubious individuals.
It seems we primarily have to thank Boucher for introducing such individuals
- and also for making Blake himself morally dubious. Blake's
'transformation' designed by Boucher starts with 'Shadow'. Someone on the
Lyst suggested the name of the episode, apart from the drug, also alludes to
the Terra Nostra being the Federation's 'shadow'. I think it's also because
Boucher has decided to turn Blake into a 'dusky' hero, past his zenith of
perfection and moral purity, whose shadow starts becoming visible. The next
step in the transformation is Star One, with those weird scenes in which
Blake's so successful in pretending he's Travis. Blake wants to destroy Star
One. Travis wants to enable the Andromedans to do the same. As Avon would
say, there must be a subtle difference which escapes me at the moment. And
then there's 'Blake', where Our Hero appears as an unshaven one-eyed bounty
hunter who shoots people in the back. I wonder what would have become of
Blake in Boucher's interpretation had the series continued. I try hard to
incorporate the changes he introduced into the character, but sometimes I
give up. In my hours of darkness I've concluded that Boucher is really a
Federation's secret agent assigned to destroy Blake's reputation.
N.